Free senior care guidance for families in Chattanooga, Cleveland and the Marion County towns. Never a cost to you.
Call (423) 216-3292
Chattanooga Senior Advisor(423) 216-3292

How to Read Nursing Home Ratings for Hamilton County Homes

CMS star ratings are a useful start but easy to misread. How to use stars, staffing hours and inspection results together.

Quick answer

CMS star ratings are a useful start but easy to misread. How to use stars, staffing hours and inspection results together.

Home›Guides›How to Read Nursing Home Ratings for Hamilton County

By Chattanooga Senior Advisor Care Team · November 11, 2026

TL;DR

Look at three things together: the health inspection results, staffing hours per resident, and quality measures. A strong recent inspection and steady staffing can matter more than the overall star number. Then visit, at different times of day.

Where the ratings come from

The Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services publishes ratings for every certified nursing home on its Care Compare site. Each home gets an overall rating from one to five stars, built from three parts: health inspections, staffing and quality measures. Our nursing home pages for Hamilton, Bradley and Marion counties show the figures from the latest CMS release we used, alongside each home's Tennessee license record.

The ratings compare homes to each other, mostly within the state. A three-star home is roughly average, not poor.

Health inspections

The inspection rating reflects the last few years of standard surveys and complaint investigations, with more weight on recent findings. Look past the star to the details: how many deficiencies were cited, how serious they were, and whether any involved harm to residents. A single citation for paperwork is very different from repeated findings about falls or medication errors.

Ask the administrator about any serious finding and what changed afterward. A clear, specific answer is a good sign.

Staffing

The staffing rating uses payroll data to measure nursing hours per resident per day, including registered nurses, licensed practical nurses and aides, and it also considers staff turnover and weekend staffing. Higher hours and lower turnover generally mean residents get more attention and staff know them better.

On a tour, ask how many residents each aide cares for on day, evening and night shifts, and how often the home uses agency staff. Visit on a weekend if you can; staffing is often thinnest then.

Quality measures

Quality measures track outcomes such as falls with injury, pressure ulcers, weight loss, antipsychotic use and rehospitalization, separately for short-stay and long-stay residents. If your parent is going for rehab, focus on the short-stay measures. For a long stay, the long-stay measures matter more.

These figures are partly self-reported and can lag by months. Use them to form questions rather than to make the final decision.

Common mistakes

The most common mistake is choosing on the overall star alone. Another is ignoring the date: a home that changed ownership or leadership recently may look different from its older data in either direction. A third is assuming every home takes both Medicare and Medicaid. Most certified homes in our area do, but check, because a home that bills Medicare only cannot keep a resident once a long stay is paid by TennCare.

Also check the Tennessee license record on each home's page for any state penalty orders, which do not always appear in the CMS summary.

Short stays versus long stays

The right home for a three-week rehab stay may not be the right home for a long stay. For rehab, look at therapy staffing, short-stay quality measures such as successful return home and rehospitalization rates, and how often the therapy team sees each patient. For a long stay, look at long-stay measures, staff turnover, activities and how residents spend their days.

If a short stay may become a long one, choose with the long stay in mind, and make sure the home accepts TennCare for long-term care in case it is needed later.

Asking the right questions on a visit

Ask how many residents each aide is assigned on each shift, how many registered nurses work nights and weekends, and how often the home uses agency staff. Ask what happened after the most recent inspection and what the home is working on now. Ask how families are kept informed of changes in condition.

Watch mealtimes and the hour after lunch, when many residents need help. Notice whether residents are up and dressed, whether call lights stay on for long, and how staff speak to people who are confused. Those observations fill in what no rating can show.

State records alongside the federal ratings

Tennessee's Health Facilities Commission licenses every nursing home and publishes disciplinary actions, including penalty orders, separately from the CMS ratings. Our nursing home pages show both: the CMS figures and the Tennessee license record. When the two point the same way, you can be fairly confident. When they differ, for example a decent star rating alongside a recent state penalty, ask the administrator to explain. Families can also ask to see the most recent inspection report, which every certified home must make available for review.

Remember that ratings describe the past. Staffing and leadership can change quickly, which is why a recent visit still matters most.

Bradley and Marion county homes are rated on the same scale, so the same approach works across all three counties. If the closest homes all look weak on paper, it can be worth a longer drive for a home with a stronger recent inspection and steadier staffing, especially for a long stay where your parent will live for months or years. Ask the hospital discharge planner which homes have current openings, then check each one here before deciding.

Putting it together

Shortlist three homes using the ratings and the inspection details, then visit each at least once without an appointment. Watch how call lights are answered, how residents look and how staff speak to them. Talk to families in the lobby if they are willing. The district ombudsman, at (423) 591-7719, can explain residents' rights and what to look for. Ratings narrow the field; visits make the choice.

Frequently asked questions

What makes up the CMS overall rating?

Health inspections, staffing and quality measures.

Is a three-star home a poor choice?

Not necessarily; three stars is roughly average.

Where can we see a home's Tennessee license record?

On its page in our directory, from Health Facilities Commission data.

Talk to a local advisor about your situation →

Where should your family start?

Five quick questions, and a local advisor will send back senior care options in the Chattanooga area matched to the care needed and the budget you have. Free, and nothing to sign.

Find care options
Find Facilities Near You